Forgive me if I'm not going to the correct place to suggest something, but I essentially found a TREASURE TROVE of absolute shit to review. Luckily, I'll spare you the misfortune of navigation, and link you to two particular stories I found and had the misfortune of reading.
You are correct! This is the best place for if you wanted to suggest stories to the Creepypasta Critic. I'll take a look at those two right after I finish up with Part 2 of Sonic.exe 2: Electric Boogaloo.